Spanberger Rejects Federal School Funding?

On Monday, the Wall Street Journal took Governor Spanberger to task for passing on $731M in scholarships for Virginia students (gift link).

“It shouldn’t be controversial for Virginia children to take advantage of the new federal program for K-12 education expenses, as students in 31 states will do. But Democratic Gov. Abigail Spanberger is telling them no.

In a particular sting, Virginia families thought they were in. Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin signed the state up for the program, which grants federal tax credits for donations to scholarships, before he left office in January. But to complete the process to join, states must submit a list of eligible scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs) to the U.S. Treasury, which they couldn’t do until October.

…

Last month the state teachers union urged Gov. Spanberger not to submit the list. On Friday her office told the Washington Post she is following the union’s orders.

What a regrettable pass on federal money that could help students pay for private school, tutoring and more. Taxpayers can get a federal credit up to $1,700, or $3,400 for married couples, for donating to SGOs. But students can get scholarships only in states that opt in.

Passing on Federal education dollars seemed out of character for a Democrat, so I decided to check it out. I found that the Journal is talking about a tax credit program called the Education Freedom Tax Credit(EFTC), which the article does not mention for some reason.

It works like this: States designate approved “scholarship-granting organizations” (SGO) and give a list of approved SGOs to the US Treasury Department. Under the EFTC, Americans who donate up to $1700 ($3400 for married couples) to one of the approved SGOs get a dollar-for-dollar tax credit – that’s a credit, not a deduction from gross income. By donating $3400, a married couple would reduce a $10,000 tax bill to $6,600. 

This amounts to a direct transfer of Federal taxpayer funds to organizations, many of them religious, chosen by individual taxpayers. 

Former Governor Youngkin signed Virginia up for the program, but left office before he could provide the list. Governor Spanberger declined to provide that list, which means Virginia will not participate.

These SGOs, many of them religious organizations (examples include the American Catholic Education Fund, the Orthodox Christian Scholarship Fund, and Renew Scholarships), use these funds to grant scholarships to students eligible to enroll in public school whose families earn no more than three times (300%) of the median gross income in the Housing and Urban Development Department (HUD) Section 8 Fair Market Rent area where they live. 

Note that this is not three times the poverty level – it’s three times the median income, which according to HUD ranges from about $163K for a family of four in Buchanan County to almost $500K for a family of four in Northern Virginia. This is not an effort to make sure kids from poor families have better access to education opportunities. Scholarship grants could, and often will, go to well-off parents who already send their kids to private religious schools.

The scholarships are not tied to the donations or tax credits; students whose parents do not donate to an SGO qualify for grants. But nothing in the law would prevent SGOs from informally connecting donations to scholarships and giving them a preference.

Rejection of the program would not mean that Virginians cannot take the tax credit if they just want to help other families. Virginia residents can still donate to a program in another State, but those funds would not benefit Virginia kids. North Carolina SGOs, for example, may grant scholarships only to North Carolina students.

A key point here is that that rejecting participation in the program does not actually mean that Virginia foregoes a $731M federal education grant to the Commonwealth. That number does not represent an estimate of how much Virginia would receive for kids under the program – it’s an estimate of how much money Virginia residents would donate to SGOs if 10% of Virginians donated and received the tax credit.

Patrick Graff of the American Federation for Children estimates that if 10% of eligible taxpayers in Virginia redirect tax payments to an SGO under the program, these organizations would receive $730.9M. This does not mean that these SGOs would then grant that full amount to students – nothing I can find restricts the use of these funds except that a Virginia SGO could only grant scholarships to Virginia students using the money. It would be free to use some of it for administrative costs, materials, salaries, and so on.

The Wall Street Journal should make this clearer.

The Journal should also avoid framing Spanberger’s decision as kowtowing to unions. To be sure, teachers’ unions advised the Governor on the program, but I can imagine several reasons why a Democratic Governor would reject this plan (though at least two, Grisham in New Mexico and Hochul in New York, have decided to participate). 

The American Federation for Children (AFC) supports the plan because it’s a national school choice program. Their unspoken goal is to kill public education, and much of their funding comes from Betsy and Dick DeVos, who want to destroy public education and push a religious agenda through school vouchers. They spoke extensively in 2001 about using school vouchers as a way to advance their religious faith:

“At a 2001Christian summit called ‘The Gathering,’ DeVos and her husband spoke 

about their work in education policy as an extension of their religious practice. In

response to a question from the moderator as to why the couple does not simply fund Christian schools rather than pushing for education reform more broadly, DeVos explained that she wished to ‘to confront the culture in which we all live today in ways which will continue to help advance God’s kingdom but not to stay in our own little faith territory.’ 

She later elaborated that her political activities were motivated by a desire ‘to impact our culture in ways that are not the traditional funding the Christian organization route, but that really may have greater Kingdom gains in the long run by changing the way we approach things, in this case the system of education in the country.’ 

Further, DeVos noted that private donations alone simply couldn’t sufficiently fund religious schools—'[t]here are not enough philanthropic dollars in America to fund what is currently the need’ to compete with government money that is not well spent.’ (See pages 17-18 in the document at the link).

Betsy and Dick DeVos support the AFC because they want to destroy secular public education and replace it with religious schools, and the AFC supports this project.

Though students who remain in public schools are eligible for the grants, these would primarily be smaller amounts for special needs children. Most of the scholarship dollars would go to parents who want to move their kids to private schools, many of them religious, or parents who have already done so. This would reduce funding for public schools and hurt those children who cannot move.

We cannot ignore the religious component here. Many of the SGOs approved for these programs have a specific agenda: get as many children as possible to religious schools. An SGO can limit its scholarship grants to students attending private religious schools, including those of a particular denomination, and some SGOs say up front that their grants will only go to students attending approved Jewish or Catholic schools. 

I wonder whether organizations like Renew Scholarships (“Opening doors to Christian Education”) would grant a scholarship to a child with atheist parents to send them to a secular private school. And though donations made to get the tax credit are not formally associated with scholarship grants, I wonder if some SGOs would informally make that a condition for granting a scholarship. Nothing I see in the law would prevent that.

This very short op-ed in the Journal tries to paint this as Abigail Spanberger passing on Federal education funding that could help Virginia children because she cares more about what union leaders think than she does about kids in the Commonwealth. 

It’s a much bigger issue than that, and it’s worth spending some time figuring out whether we want to let billionaires undermine our education system to push their religious silliness.

I say no, and I support Governor Spanberger’s decision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.