Mark Halperin Thinks Abdul El Sayed Was Mean to JD Vance and Mike Rogers

Looking at my feed on X this morning (yeah, I know) I stumbled upon something called “2WAY,” (@2waytvapp on X), a video commentary platform founded by Mark Halperin and Arnold Jung back in 2024. You may remember Halperin from 2017 sexual harassment accusations from almost a dozen women. I can’t find any evidence that anyone ever substantiated these claims, but they derailed his pundit career for several years.

In any event he’s back, now sharing his thoughts at 2Way, and I managed to catch a short clip on X. In the clip, he argues that Senator-elect Abdul El Sayed from Michigan will not become a dominant figure in Congress because he “doesn’t play nicely.”

“A freshman senator who comes in and acts the way he does? I don’t think that’s going to go over particularly well with his older peers. Last night he insulted the vice president. He was extremely rude and crude to Mike Rogers.” 

He’s talking about comments El Sayed made during the campaign and in his victory speech Tuesday night.

To Vance he said, “JD, habibi,” followed by his delight that Vance would have to swear him in, and then said “Wolverine one, Buckeye zero” referencing the Ohio State Michigan football rivalry. Using “habibi” this way is an Arabic equivalent of “Bless your Heart,” and any Southerner will get the meaning. Any football fan would characterize the football jab as on the order of “locker room talk.”

To Rogers, El Sayed said, “You chose hate and Michigan chose hope. May we never have to see the likes of you in this state again.”

Nothing “rude and crude” here, but Halperin has to call him out without saying a thing about all the nasty things Vance and Rogers had to say during the campaign. For example, on August 31, Vance said “there’s something about Abdul El-Sayed that is very, very evil,” and called him “a little weasel” on October 15. 

Rogers has called El Sayed a con man, and when asked if he’s a terrorist responded “Look at the data. It’s pretty clear.” He also accused El Sayed of believing that “America deserved 9/11.”

All of this is a classic case of the “both sides” pundit bashing a Democrat for occasionally doing something Republicans do every day and on a different level. He also completely ignores any evidence that El Sayed will be able to build relationships with is Senate colleagues, not the least of which is that he managed to get dozens of Michigan and other Democrats to support his campaign. 

I also find it very interesting that Halperin doesn’t seem to think competence and grasp of policy will matter here. Halperin apparently thinks we still live in a world where the US Senate is some kind of collegial deliberative body where they all adjourn to the cloak room for cigars and bourbon after the Committee hearings end.

I never thought Halperin was such a great pundit and this kind of silly analysis of the situation exposes him as a hack. He’s always been a ”both sides” centrist – when discussing Trump’s first term, for example, he focused on why Trump appeals to some voters rather than criticizing his corruption, graft, and rhetoric. 

I’m old enough to remember when pundits did this to avoid the “liberal bias” label, which is fair enough, I guess. But in practice it comes down to an attempt to look moderate while bashing people you don’t like while overlooking worse flaws in others. Halperin always had something bad to say about both sides of policy disputes, even in cases where one was clearly the bad actor. 

He’s not doing that here. Here I think he just wants to say something bad about El Sayed for some reason. Even to the extent he has a point, I’m not sure this means El Sayed will never be a dominant figure in Congress. He’ll have a learning curve, to be sure, but I think he’ll do well because he has a clear grasp of policy and is willing to stand up to Republican bullies. 

“When they go low, we go high” just didn’t work, and Democrats are sick and tired of watching conservatives fight hard for what they believe in while Democrats hem and haw and waffle. We’re tired of watching conservative bullies get away with telling lies and calling names (Talafreako!). We’re over listening to conservative accusations of treason and hatred of the country we grew up in – and many of us served in the military – while our side tries to work with them to govern. We’re tired of watching Republicans accuse our neighbors of eating pets without someone calling them out for their bullshit.

We want Senators and Representatives and Presidents who stand up for our values and fight to protect the people, blue and red, who are falling behind by pushing good policy. 

What Halperin describes as “rude and crude” meanness is standard rhetoric for conservatives, and Democrats voted for El Sayed because we’re ready for someone willing to give as good as he gets. This may or may not degrade American politics, but Republicans started it.

About time Democrats pushed back, and I’m glad we elected brilliant Senators like El Sayed to do it. 

Oh, yes…Habibi, JD.

Foxtrot. Delta. Tango.

It’s very difficult to overstate the epic beat down Democrats just laid on the MAGA coalition in a big Foxtrot Delta Tango to Donald Trump and his neofascism. Nothing like this has happened since the post-Watergate Democratic wave in 1974.

Yesterday I predicted a 235-vote House majority and perhaps 53 Democrats in the US Senate. I correctly saw wins in Texas, Iowa, and Kansas, but never dreamed that Annie Andrews could win in South Carolina. I also expected Susan Collins to hold on in Maine. I was far too conservative.

The notion that Mississippi might still be a dead heat at 10 AM the next morning never occurred to me. 

I also didn’t see the Shannon Taylor flip in Virginia’s First District. I thought she would come close, but that Tea Party voters in the rural counties would stay home and show up to help Wittman squeak by. I didn’t see a wave big enough to flip this district coming.

I think I got most of the reasons for this right, and I correctly noted in past videos that progressives could win elections in battleground states even with a funding disadvantage (see Texas and Michigan). Elon Muskburned through something like $250M in Texas alone, and the Koch brothers, AIPAC, and financial sector donors outspent Democrats by $94M in Ohio and $32M in Michigan. Money alone does not win campaigns.

One key thing I did miss: the huge turnout increases among minority voters and voters under 30, with lots of overlap. It appears that black voters showed up for Dems in Southern states and Michigan in response to SCOTUS gutting the Voting Rights Act and subsequent gerrymandering. Hispanic voters, who formed a key component of Trump’s 2024 coalition, ran as fast as they could back to Democrats in response to the way ICE has treated their communities. And young voters – including young men! – voted for Democrats, They almost doubled their 2024 turnout where candidates gave them something to vote for (e.g., medicare for all and an end to genocide in Gaza).

These shifts helped Democrats win in Michigan, Texas and South Carolina, and made a state that normally gets called fifteen minutes after polls close, Mississippi, to remain essentially tied the next morning. 

Also, too, a look at outstanding votes suggests that Scott Colom has a decent chance to give Democrats a 55-45 Senate Majority, and I now think he’ll pull it out. If Peltola pulls it off in Alaska, Dems will have 56 votes in the Senate and still have 55 even if Fetterman switches parties.

Simply. Unbelievable. 

I’ll spend the week parsing data as it comes in, and Scott and I will have much more later this week on Two Crusty Old Combat Soldiers with a Microphone and Foggy Bottom Line Live. I’ll also put together some thoughts on what Democrats should do with these majorities (The obvious corruption investigations and impeachments, of course, but Dems should also pass progressive legislation on data centers, AI, wealth taxes, health care, and restoration of DOGE cuts). Trump will veto any legislation Dems pass, but this gets GOP reps on the record and forces Trump to own it.

Democrats also did very well down ballot, flipping most of the statewide offices in Texas and Governor’s offices in Ohio, Texas, and Iowa. If the Party had gone big in Florida, David Jolly and Angie Nixon might have also won. A referendum in Missouri that would have repealed abortion rights and ban gender transition failed. All three Constitutional Amendments won in Virginia by wide margins, with reproductive rights at 60%.

If you’re a Democrat, savor this very clear rejection of GOP fascist politics that rely on fear of out groups and collaborating with billionaires to make everyone else poor. Progressives won this thing, and we should celebrate the win.

If you’re a Republican, pay attention to this message. If you want to win, you have to reject Trump and his corruption, give up on the culture wars and immigration rage, and come up with policies that help Americans get by.

More to come this week.

Election Day: Foggy Predictions and Other Thoughts

BLUF: This will be a blue wave that will give Democrats control of the US House of Representatives and the US Senate. The wave in the House will be at least a 20 seat change and give Democrats something like a 235-200 majority, and Democrats will control the Senate 53-47. Closer to home, Shannon Taylor will not flip VA CD01.

I can list a lot of reasons why I think this will happen.

  • Young voters who showed up for Trump and other Republicans in 2024 will defect because they did not get the fundamental change – an end to forever wars and a focus on affordability – the voted for. The  capitalist system writ large does not work for them and they figure “might as well break it.” .
  • Young voters also want an end to genocide in Gaza. Social media and the internet ensure that everyone sees video of children being killed there whether they want to or not. This will cause young (and some older) Americans to seek the fundamental change they want from candidates who will promise to stop this genocide. 
  • Culture war rhetoric about trans kids and gay marriage no longer resonate with rural Americans while rising fuel prices and tariffs destroy their farms and the foreign markets for their produce. 
  • Voters are sick of watching billionaires push artificial intelligence from private planes and yachts while AI takes their jobs and housing, fuel, and grocery prices rise rapidly. 
  • Even though wages are rising with prices, people don’t feel this because right to work and at will employment laws make white collar workers anxious about their financial futures. News reports of layoffs have an impact.
  • Health care costs are out of control and voters know whom to blame: health insurance companies and politicians who argue that if you can’t afford it you don’t deserve it. Most voters work very hard and are beginning to become pissed at Republicans who tell them to just work harder. The (correct) feeling that the system is rigged against regular workers is gaining traction. $225B in medical debt has begun to hit Republican voters and it matters.
  • Screaming about who loves and who hates America doesn’t resonate as well during hard times. Voters, especially young voters, don’t have many reasons to love a country that leaves them behind while making them feel like it’s their fault after they did all the right things.
  • Americans want criminal immigrants deported but despise the heavy-handed Gestapo style tactics ICE uses. Watching federal agents who often refuse to identify themselves and do not wear uniforms randomly round up people because they have brown skin leaves a bad taste in their mouths. It doesn’t help that they shoot or assault citizens and then tell us that we won’t have a problem if we just comply.
  • Traditional GOP voters in rural areas, especially farmers, have been hit hard by higher fuel prices (especially diesel) and by tariffs that killed foreign markets for crops like soybeans. Rural America does not have diverse economies, and when agriculture dies the small towns where they do business struggle.
  • Democrats have effectively tied affordability to Trump’s obvious corruption and higher prices to Trump tariff and war policies.

There’s a lot more. What Corey Doctorow calls “enshittification” of everything. Data centers popping up everywhere. Everyone everywhere trying to nickel and dime us wherever we turn (tip jars at fast food restaurants and service fees for everything).

Continue reading →

Midterm Strategy: Ditch the Corporate Consultants for a GOP Performance Review

We’re 30 days out. Democrats look like they’re looking at a blue wave that could shift control of Congress from Republican to Democrat, maybe even the Senate. I want to talk about strategy a little bit because I’m seeing a lot of ads on TV that boil down to, “we gotta stop insider stock trading.” And you’re seeing that from both sides…even the guys that are doing it are bragging about voting for legislation that would stop it.

But Democrats are giving us the same old ads about how mom and dad taught me to work hard and I’ll work hard for you. I was a good prosecutor or state legislator or governor or businessman.

This is the same old corporate consultant bullshit that Democrats have been using to lose since 2016, and it’s time to change it up a little bit. Trump’s been president twice. The GOP has controlled all three branches of government for two years. And they still blame Biden for high gasoline prices.

It’s not Biden’s fault. They’ve had a chance to fix it. They haven’t fixed it.

So it’s time to do two things as a strategy for the midterms for Democrats in these last thirty days.

First, make this election a performance review. The GOP asked for control of Congress and the Senate and the presidency two years ago, and Americans gave it to them. They promised to make life more affordable and keep us out of war.

They did neither, and this begs the old Reagan question: Is your life better now than it was when we gave it to them?

The American people gave them control. We gave them power. What’d they use it for? Tax cuts for billionaires. They didn’t use it to bring your grocery prices down. They didn’t use it to bring your gasoline prices down. They didn’t use it to bring your housing prices down. And in fact, they got us into a war they promised not to get us into that raised all those prices.

Make Republicans talk about their performance just like you would at a job. If you’re a manager at a job, someone’s not performing, you talk to them and you fire them if they don’t straighten up and fly right.

The second thing we need to do is point out that the hundreds of millions of dollars corporations and billionaires and special interests are spending to try to win these seats demonstrates that they like the status quo. They want the status quo.

Seven dollar diesel is good for them because they’re selling diesel. It’s not good for you because you have to buy it to fill your truck up.

The same old corporate consultant stuff doesn’t work. These TV ads don’t change anybody’s minds. They just don’t. They may be good for pointing out to people who don’t pay much attention that there is an election, but they’re not changing anyone’s minds. No one is voting for Shannon Taylor because she said “Mom and dad taught me that hard work would bring success, but that doesn’t happen if we don’t stop the corruption” in a TV ad.

She’s right about that, but it’s not changing anyone’s mind. Instead, Shannon Taylor and other democrats need to be online saying it again and again: they promised to fix it and they just broke it even more.

Hammer home the fact that we gave the Republicans control of all three branches of government two years ago, and they’ve done nothing but create chaos and make things more expensive for everyone. It’s time to hold their feet to the fire because they didn’t do the job we hired them to do.

Point out that the corporations like the status quo just fine because they have power, they have no regulation, they have their tax cuts, and if they keep the same people in power, they’ll just get less regulation and more tax cuts.

And your housing will go up, your fuel costs will go up, your grocery bill will go up. Your interest rates on your credit card will go up because that’s all good for them. It’s all good for the corporations that are dropping millions in these elections blaming immigrants and trans people for the problems they caused.

You can’t blame Joe Biden for $7 diesel. The trans person is not causing $7 diesel fuel. Women who want reproductive health care are not causing $7 diesel fuel.

Republicans have had two years to fix it and they’ve only made it worse.  It’s time to hold their feet to the fire.