Spanberger Rejects Federal School Funding?

On Monday, the Wall Street Journal took Governor Spanberger to task for passing on $731M in scholarships for Virginia students (gift link).

“It shouldn’t be controversial for Virginia children to take advantage of the new federal program for K-12 education expenses, as students in 31 states will do. But Democratic Gov. Abigail Spanberger is telling them no.

In a particular sting, Virginia families thought they were in. Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin signed the state up for the program, which grants federal tax credits for donations to scholarships, before he left office in January. But to complete the process to join, states must submit a list of eligible scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs) to the U.S. Treasury, which they couldn’t do until October.

…

Last month the state teachers union urged Gov. Spanberger not to submit the list. On Friday her office told the Washington Post she is following the union’s orders.

What a regrettable pass on federal money that could help students pay for private school, tutoring and more. Taxpayers can get a federal credit up to $1,700, or $3,400 for married couples, for donating to SGOs. But students can get scholarships only in states that opt in.

Passing on Federal education dollars seemed out of character for a Democrat, so I decided to check it out. I found that the Journal is talking about a tax credit program called the Education Freedom Tax Credit(EFTC), which the article does not mention for some reason.

It works like this: States designate approved “scholarship-granting organizations” (SGO) and give a list of approved SGOs to the US Treasury Department. Under the EFTC, Americans who donate up to $1700 ($3400 for married couples) to one of the approved SGOs get a dollar-for-dollar tax credit – that’s a credit, not a deduction from gross income. By donating $3400, a married couple would reduce a $10,000 tax bill to $6,600. 

This amounts to a direct transfer of Federal taxpayer funds to organizations, many of them religious, chosen by individual taxpayers. 

Former Governor Youngkin signed Virginia up for the program, but left office before he could provide the list. Governor Spanberger declined to provide that list, which means Virginia will not participate.

These SGOs, many of them religious organizations (examples include the American Catholic Education Fund, the Orthodox Christian Scholarship Fund, and Renew Scholarships), use these funds to grant scholarships to students eligible to enroll in public school whose families earn no more than three times (300%) of the median gross income in the Housing and Urban Development Department (HUD) Section 8 Fair Market Rent area where they live. 

Note that this is not three times the poverty level – it’s three times the median income, which according to HUD ranges from about $163K for a family of four in Buchanan County to almost $500K for a family of four in Northern Virginia. This is not an effort to make sure kids from poor families have better access to education opportunities. Scholarship grants could, and often will, go to well-off parents who already send their kids to private religious schools.

The scholarships are not tied to the donations or tax credits; students whose parents do not donate to an SGO qualify for grants. But nothing in the law would prevent SGOs from informally connecting donations to scholarships and giving them a preference.

Rejection of the program would not mean that Virginians cannot take the tax credit if they just want to help other families. Virginia residents can still donate to a program in another State, but those funds would not benefit Virginia kids. North Carolina SGOs, for example, may grant scholarships only to North Carolina students.

A key point here is that that rejecting participation in the program does not actually mean that Virginia foregoes a $731M federal education grant to the Commonwealth. That number does not represent an estimate of how much Virginia would receive for kids under the program – it’s an estimate of how much money Virginia residents would donate to SGOs if 10% of Virginians donated and received the tax credit.

Patrick Graff of the American Federation for Children estimates that if 10% of eligible taxpayers in Virginia redirect tax payments to an SGO under the program, these organizations would receive $730.9M. This does not mean that these SGOs would then grant that full amount to students – nothing I can find restricts the use of these funds except that a Virginia SGO could only grant scholarships to Virginia students using the money. It would be free to use some of it for administrative costs, materials, salaries, and so on.

The Wall Street Journal should make this clearer.

The Journal should also avoid framing Spanberger’s decision as kowtowing to unions. To be sure, teachers’ unions advised the Governor on the program, but I can imagine several reasons why a Democratic Governor would reject this plan (though at least two, Grisham in New Mexico and Hochul in New York, have decided to participate). 

The American Federation for Children (AFC) supports the plan because it’s a national school choice program. Their unspoken goal is to kill public education, and much of their funding comes from Betsy and Dick DeVos, who want to destroy public education and push a religious agenda through school vouchers. They spoke extensively in 2001 about using school vouchers as a way to advance their religious faith:

“At a 2001Christian summit called ‘The Gathering,’ DeVos and her husband spoke 

about their work in education policy as an extension of their religious practice. In

response to a question from the moderator as to why the couple does not simply fund Christian schools rather than pushing for education reform more broadly, DeVos explained that she wished to ‘to confront the culture in which we all live today in ways which will continue to help advance God’s kingdom but not to stay in our own little faith territory.’ 

She later elaborated that her political activities were motivated by a desire ‘to impact our culture in ways that are not the traditional funding the Christian organization route, but that really may have greater Kingdom gains in the long run by changing the way we approach things, in this case the system of education in the country.’ 

Further, DeVos noted that private donations alone simply couldn’t sufficiently fund religious schools—'[t]here are not enough philanthropic dollars in America to fund what is currently the need’ to compete with government money that is not well spent.’ (See pages 17-18 in the document at the link).

Betsy and Dick DeVos support the AFC because they want to destroy secular public education and replace it with religious schools, and the AFC supports this project.

Though students who remain in public schools are eligible for the grants, these would primarily be smaller amounts for special needs children. Most of the scholarship dollars would go to parents who want to move their kids to private schools, many of them religious, or parents who have already done so. This would reduce funding for public schools and hurt those children who cannot move.

We cannot ignore the religious component here. Many of the SGOs approved for these programs have a specific agenda: get as many children as possible to religious schools. An SGO can limit its scholarship grants to students attending private religious schools, including those of a particular denomination, and some SGOs say up front that their grants will only go to students attending approved Jewish or Catholic schools. 

I wonder whether organizations like Renew Scholarships (“Opening doors to Christian Education”) would grant a scholarship to a child with atheist parents to send them to a secular private school. And though donations made to get the tax credit are not formally associated with scholarship grants, I wonder if some SGOs would informally make that a condition for granting a scholarship. Nothing I see in the law would prevent that.

This very short op-ed in the Journal tries to paint this as Abigail Spanberger passing on Federal education funding that could help Virginia children because she cares more about what union leaders think than she does about kids in the Commonwealth. 

It’s a much bigger issue than that, and it’s worth spending some time figuring out whether we want to let billionaires undermine our education system to push their religious silliness.

I say no, and I support Governor Spanberger’s decision.

I Read the Medicare for All Act So You Don’t Have To – Join me on Foggy Bottom Live This Week to Discuss

One key takeaway from the midterm election results is that Americans want the US health care system fixed. They’re tired of rising costs, surprise bills, and a system that only a math genius can successfully navigate. That’s why so many Democrats ran on universal health care access, sometimes referred to as Medicare for All.

Some years ago I wrote a white paper for a Congressional candidate about just what is in this legislation – yes, I read the whole thing – and the political problems with enactment might look like. This analysis covers the Medicare for All Act of 2019, including Bernie Sanders’ Senate (S. 1129) and its sister House version (HR 1384) introduced by Representative Jayapal. Since then, the two have introduced revised versions with some very small changes. The House and Senate versions don’t differ much. Since this was a big issue during the recent campaigns, I want to revisit the issue, and I’ll do that on the live show on Friday. In the meantime, here’s the paper I wrote a while back.

BLUF: This legislation establishes a universal health care program under existing Social Security Act (which established Medicare) definitions and its “global health budget” system for paying providers.It provides robust coverage, including long term care, dental, hearing aids, and vision, with no deductibles, co-pays, or cost share. The law does not ban private health insurance, but pretty much limits their market to services not covered by M4A (a very narrow market) and clients who are not eligible for M4A. The legislation directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services to negotiate drug prices and would give the Secretary a lot of power to establish rules for this program.

Services are funded through a Universal Medicare Trust Fund that places all federal heath care program funding in a central account. Medicare, Medicaid, Tricare (retired military health care), and other federal health care programs would consolidate. The funding stream would cover something like a third of the total cost of the program, so additional funding would be needed.

Program Outline

Basically, this legislation would expand Medicare eligibility to “every individual who is a resident of the United States” and give the Secretary of Health and Human Services power to define residency for the purpose of eligibility determination.  The program would take effect two years after enactment of the law (four years in the Senate version). During this transition period Americans could keep their current coverage or purchase Medicare coverage as a public option on the Affordable Care Act Exchange.

Under the House version the broad spectrum of benefits under M4A would become available immediately to those buying in. Benefits under the Senate version would mirror what Medicare recipients receive today except that it caps cost-shares and deductibles at fairly low levels.

The House version tasks the Administrator of the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services to set buy-in premiums according to family size, age, and tobacco status consistent with the Public Health Service Act. Under the Senate version, the buy-in premium would be the per capita cost of providing all Medicare benefits as estimated by the Secretary of Health and Human Services. Provisions in both versions set up subsidies for low-income Americans that mirror provisions of the Affordable Care Act.

The Secretary would administer this program through regional offices that would provide needs assessments, recommend changes in provider reimbursements (including regional variations) and create a quality assurance mechanism for their regions.

Both bills include a provision exempting M4A from application of the Hyde Amendment. This means federal funds could be used to pay for abortions under Medicare for All.

Private Insurance and Providers

This law does not ban private health insurance. Carriers may not, however, offer plans that duplicate benefits covered under the Act. Medicare for all offers a comprehensive set of benefits, including preventive care, medications, mental health, oral health, audiology and vision coverage, and long-term care services and support. What a private plan might offer beyond this is not clear. Medicare for All would require no cost-share of any kind, including deductibles, copayments or similar charges. Care and treatment would cost nothing at the point of delivery.

The government does not directly hire providers and does not nationalize any health care operations, infrastructure, or systems. Providers, including individual doctors, hospitals, group practices, and others may provide services under the Program if licensed or certified in their State. Participating providers may contract with individuals to offer services not covered by the Program or to individuals not covered by the Act. Providers may also opt out of the Program entirely and provide any services to anyone they wish. 

Budgeting and Provider Payments

Title VI of the Act directs the Secretary to establish a global national health care budgetto pay for operations (providing services), capital expenditures, special projects (mostly focused on rural and other medically underserved areas), and other costs. This budget includes a reserve fund for pandemic or national disaster response. 

The Program pays institutional providers quarterly lump sums for services based on annual negotiations between providers and regional directors. These negotiations would consider a variety of factors, including historical volume of services, but excluding capital expenditures or compensation for executives or Board members. Individual practitioners may provide services according to a fee schedule determined by the Secretary. The Secretary will also create a standardized review process similar to the existing “relative value” system currently used for Medicare to ensure accurate valuation of services.

Section 616 of Title VI directs the Secretary to annually negotiate prices for drugs, medical supplies, technologies, and equipment. These negotiations must consider corporate and government investment in development of the drug or item and clinical effectiveness. If negotiations fail, the Secretary may authorize another firm to use data from clinical trials and other patent information to manufacture the item. This is a critical section since it does a lot to keep costs down.

Funding the Program

Title VII of the Act creates the Universal Medicare Trust Fund and transfers appropriations from Medicare, Medicaid, FEHB, Tricare, maternal and child health programs, and other monies to the Trust Fund. In 2022, this amounted to about $1.5 trillion in direct appropriations or other funds, but this would only cover about a third of the cost of single payer. Congress would have to find new revenue streams to pay for this program.

A 10% tax on all income from every source would yield about $1.8 trillion, which almost gets us there, and this tax would hit wealthier people harder since it would apply to capital gains and other investment income as well as regular incomes over the existing cap. If this tax simply shifts premium and out of pocket health care costs from a payment to a private firm to a tax payment, many Americans would be better off financially.

Political Implications

This legislation should concern a variety of interest groups. Passing a version of this bill would not ban private health insurance firms but would virtually eliminate their markets, motivating both corporate executives and front-line workers against the plan. They could contract with individuals or organizations to provide health care insurance plans but could not offer plans that mirror M4A benefits to people eligible for this Program. They could offer plans comparable to M4A only to those who don’t qualify (mostly undocumented immigrants and foreigners). They could presumably cover equipment, services, treatments, and medications M4A does not, a narrow scope of services indeed.

Neither version nationalizes the health care system, and no doctor or other health care provider becomes a government employee. Providers who do not wish to participate as providers in the M4A program could contract with individuals to provide health care (not insurance) and could mirror M4A benefits. Those who do would have to accept payment under fee-for-service or negotiated compensation that would have to look a lot like existing Medicare reimbursement levels. Most providers effectively become government contractors, and many would object to this unless well-compensated. Since calculations of program cost depend on the total US outlay for health care expenses, it would make sense to shift some health insurance corporation profit and executive pay to doctors by raising reimbursement rates.

Pharmaceutical firms will push back hard because it allows government to use its demand-side market power to negotiate drug prices down. It could even ignore patent protection if a firm could not come to terms on price. Since government would under these plans purchase most of the medications traded in the US, this would seriously cut into their profits.

Evangelical groups would also strongly oppose this program because it allows using federal funds to pay for abortions. They Hyde Amendment would not apply to Medicare for All. Veteran and union organizations will act to protect the excellent health care they earned through military service or decades of blue-collar work.

Building popular support for this will depend on convincing people who have good health care plans that giving them up will improve their lives in the long run. Lots of people hate the convoluted way their health insurance provider decides who get what care, when, and how they pay for it. But they know what they have, understand it, and use it for ongoing care they don’t want disrupted. Changing their minds on this won’t be a walk in the park.

Finally, even if supporters of Medicare for All could persuade health care sector corporations, doctors, evangelicals, veterans, and patients of all kinds that this legislation would make their lives better, it’s unlikely to survive Constitutional challenge given the current makeup of the Supreme Court. Today’s Supreme Court simply won’t allow a law prohibiting the sale of particular health care plans to take effect.

This legislation does not socialize medicine in the sense that it takes control of the means of health care production. Doctors don’t become government employees, and hospitals, whether or not for profit, don’t become government agencies. But it does, as a practical matter, nationalize the health insurance sector of the US market. This is, in the long run, good policy. It would make us healthier and cost us less. But passing it will be a big lift.

While we’re working on persuading our fellow Americans that it makes sense, let’s give them a private plan: Medicare buy-in through the ACA exchanges.

Trump Taps Racist Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff

Stephen Miller and Joseph Goebbels

Donald Trump has tapped racist white nationalist Stephen Miller to replace Susan Wiles as Chief of Stafffollowing the MAGA Midterm Meltdown.

“Hatewatch reviewed more than 900 previously private emails Miller sent to Breitbart editors from March 4, 2015, to June 27, 2016. Miller does not converse along a wide range of topics in the emails. His focus is strikingly narrow – more than 80 percent of the emails Hatewatch reviewed relate to or appear on threads relating to the subjects of race or immigration. Hatewatch made multiple attempts to reach the White House for a comment from Miller about the content of his emails but did not receive any reply.

Miller’s perspective on race and immigration across the emails is repetitious. When discussing crime, which he does scores of times, Miller focuses on offenses committed by nonwhites. On immigration, he touches solely on the perspective of severely limiting or ending nonwhite immigration to the United States. Hatewatch was unable to find any examples of Miller writing sympathetically or even in neutral tones about any person who is nonwhite or foreign-born.”

Miller is the architect of Trump’s deportation system, which includes what amounts to concentration camps, with over 73K detainees in 225 facilities, most of them in privately held for-profit prisons under inhumane conditions. Miller has also blocked plans to construct immigration facilities that are more humane. 

He said at a Trump campaign rally in New York that “America is for Americans” and believes that birthright citizenship amounts to civilizational suicide. He shared links to a VDARE article by Steve Sailer. He recommended Camp of the Saints, a novel popular among white nationalists and neo-nazis, to Breitbart. 

“Miller recommended in a Sept. 6, 2015, email that Breitbart write about “The Camp of the Saints,” a racist French novel by Jean Raspail. Notably, “The Camp of the Saints” is popular among white nationalists and neo-Nazis because of the degree to which it fictionalizes the “white genocide” or “great replacement” myth into a violent and sexualized story about refugees.

The novel’s apocalyptic plot centers on a flotilla of Indian people who invade France, led by a nonwhite Indian-born antagonist referred to as the “turd eater” – a character who literally eats human feces. In one section, a white woman is raped to death by brown-skinned refugees. In another, a nationalist character shoots and kills a pro-refugee leftist over his support of race mixing. The white nationalist Social Contract Press plucked the 1973 book from relative obscurity and distributed it in the United States.”

For Stephen Miller, immigration isn’t the issue. He just wants to cleanse the US of immigrants he doesn’t like – he’s fine with white farmers from South Africa coming here. 

It’s just the brown ones he wants to imprison and deport, and Americans need to keep this in mind.

Mark Halperin Thinks Abdul El Sayed Was Mean to JD Vance and Mike Rogers

Looking at my feed on X this morning (yeah, I know) I stumbled upon something called “2WAY,” (@2waytvapp on X), a video commentary platform founded by Mark Halperin and Arnold Jung back in 2024. You may remember Halperin from 2017 sexual harassment accusations from almost a dozen women. I can’t find any evidence that anyone ever substantiated these claims, but they derailed his pundit career for several years.

In any event he’s back, now sharing his thoughts at 2Way, and I managed to catch a short clip on X. In the clip, he argues that Senator-elect Abdul El Sayed from Michigan will not become a dominant figure in Congress because he “doesn’t play nicely.”

“A freshman senator who comes in and acts the way he does? I don’t think that’s going to go over particularly well with his older peers. Last night he insulted the vice president. He was extremely rude and crude to Mike Rogers.” 

He’s talking about comments El Sayed made during the campaign and in his victory speech Tuesday night.

To Vance he said, “JD, habibi,” followed by his delight that Vance would have to swear him in, and then said “Wolverine one, Buckeye zero” referencing the Ohio State Michigan football rivalry. Using “habibi” this way is an Arabic equivalent of “Bless your Heart,” and any Southerner will get the meaning. Any football fan would characterize the football jab as on the order of “locker room talk.”

To Rogers, El Sayed said, “You chose hate and Michigan chose hope. May we never have to see the likes of you in this state again.”

Nothing “rude and crude” here, but Halperin has to call him out without saying a thing about all the nasty things Vance and Rogers had to say during the campaign. For example, on August 31, Vance said “there’s something about Abdul El-Sayed that is very, very evil,” and called him “a little weasel” on October 15. 

Rogers has called El Sayed a con man, and when asked if he’s a terrorist responded “Look at the data. It’s pretty clear.” He also accused El Sayed of believing that “America deserved 9/11.”

All of this is a classic case of the “both sides” pundit bashing a Democrat for occasionally doing something Republicans do every day and on a different level. He also completely ignores any evidence that El Sayed will be able to build relationships with is Senate colleagues, not the least of which is that he managed to get dozens of Michigan and other Democrats to support his campaign. 

I also find it very interesting that Halperin doesn’t seem to think competence and grasp of policy will matter here. Halperin apparently thinks we still live in a world where the US Senate is some kind of collegial deliberative body where they all adjourn to the cloak room for cigars and bourbon after the Committee hearings end.

I never thought Halperin was such a great pundit and this kind of silly analysis of the situation exposes him as a hack. He’s always been a ”both sides” centrist – when discussing Trump’s first term, for example, he focused on why Trump appeals to some voters rather than criticizing his corruption, graft, and rhetoric. 

I’m old enough to remember when pundits did this to avoid the “liberal bias” label, which is fair enough, I guess. But in practice it comes down to an attempt to look moderate while bashing people you don’t like while overlooking worse flaws in others. Halperin always had something bad to say about both sides of policy disputes, even in cases where one was clearly the bad actor. 

He’s not doing that here. Here I think he just wants to say something bad about El Sayed for some reason. Even to the extent he has a point, I’m not sure this means El Sayed will never be a dominant figure in Congress. He’ll have a learning curve, to be sure, but I think he’ll do well because he has a clear grasp of policy and is willing to stand up to Republican bullies. 

“When they go low, we go high” just didn’t work, and Democrats are sick and tired of watching conservatives fight hard for what they believe in while Democrats hem and haw and waffle. We’re tired of watching conservative bullies get away with telling lies and calling names (Talafreako!). We’re over listening to conservative accusations of treason and hatred of the country we grew up in – and many of us served in the military – while our side tries to work with them to govern. We’re tired of watching Republicans accuse our neighbors of eating pets without someone calling them out for their bullshit.

We want Senators and Representatives and Presidents who stand up for our values and fight to protect the people, blue and red, who are falling behind by pushing good policy. 

What Halperin describes as “rude and crude” meanness is standard rhetoric for conservatives, and Democrats voted for El Sayed because we’re ready for someone willing to give as good as he gets. This may or may not degrade American politics, but Republicans started it.

About time Democrats pushed back, and I’m glad we elected brilliant Senators like El Sayed to do it. 

Oh, yes…Habibi, JD.

Foxtrot. Delta. Tango.

It’s very difficult to overstate the epic beat down Democrats just laid on the MAGA coalition in a big Foxtrot Delta Tango to Donald Trump and his neofascism. Nothing like this has happened since the post-Watergate Democratic wave in 1974.

Yesterday I predicted a 235-vote House majority and perhaps 53 Democrats in the US Senate. I correctly saw wins in Texas, Iowa, and Kansas, but never dreamed that Annie Andrews could win in South Carolina. I also expected Susan Collins to hold on in Maine. I was far too conservative.

The notion that Mississippi might still be a dead heat at 10 AM the next morning never occurred to me. 

I also didn’t see the Shannon Taylor flip in Virginia’s First District. I thought she would come close, but that Tea Party voters in the rural counties would stay home and show up to help Wittman squeak by. I didn’t see a wave big enough to flip this district coming.

I think I got most of the reasons for this right, and I correctly noted in past videos that progressives could win elections in battleground states even with a funding disadvantage (see Texas and Michigan). Elon Muskburned through something like $250M in Texas alone, and the Koch brothers, AIPAC, and financial sector donors outspent Democrats by $94M in Ohio and $32M in Michigan. Money alone does not win campaigns.

One key thing I did miss: the huge turnout increases among minority voters and voters under 30, with lots of overlap. It appears that black voters showed up for Dems in Southern states and Michigan in response to SCOTUS gutting the Voting Rights Act and subsequent gerrymandering. Hispanic voters, who formed a key component of Trump’s 2024 coalition, ran as fast as they could back to Democrats in response to the way ICE has treated their communities. And young voters – including young men! – voted for Democrats, They almost doubled their 2024 turnout where candidates gave them something to vote for (e.g., medicare for all and an end to genocide in Gaza).

These shifts helped Democrats win in Michigan, Texas and South Carolina, and made a state that normally gets called fifteen minutes after polls close, Mississippi, to remain essentially tied the next morning. 

Also, too, a look at outstanding votes suggests that Scott Colom has a decent chance to give Democrats a 55-45 Senate Majority, and I now think he’ll pull it out. If Peltola pulls it off in Alaska, Dems will have 56 votes in the Senate and still have 55 even if Fetterman switches parties.

Simply. Unbelievable. 

I’ll spend the week parsing data as it comes in, and Scott and I will have much more later this week on Two Crusty Old Combat Soldiers with a Microphone and Foggy Bottom Line Live. I’ll also put together some thoughts on what Democrats should do with these majorities (The obvious corruption investigations and impeachments, of course, but Dems should also pass progressive legislation on data centers, AI, wealth taxes, health care, and restoration of DOGE cuts). Trump will veto any legislation Dems pass, but this gets GOP reps on the record and forces Trump to own it.

Democrats also did very well down ballot, flipping most of the statewide offices in Texas and Governor’s offices in Ohio, Texas, and Iowa. If the Party had gone big in Florida, David Jolly and Angie Nixon might have also won. A referendum in Missouri that would have repealed abortion rights and ban gender transition failed. All three Constitutional Amendments won in Virginia by wide margins, with reproductive rights at 60%.

If you’re a Democrat, savor this very clear rejection of GOP fascist politics that rely on fear of out groups and collaborating with billionaires to make everyone else poor. Progressives won this thing, and we should celebrate the win.

If you’re a Republican, pay attention to this message. If you want to win, you have to reject Trump and his corruption, give up on the culture wars and immigration rage, and come up with policies that help Americans get by.

More to come this week.

Election Day: Foggy Predictions and Other Thoughts

BLUF: This will be a blue wave that will give Democrats control of the US House of Representatives and the US Senate. The wave in the House will be at least a 20 seat change and give Democrats something like a 235-200 majority, and Democrats will control the Senate 53-47. Closer to home, Shannon Taylor will not flip VA CD01.

I can list a lot of reasons why I think this will happen.

  • Young voters who showed up for Trump and other Republicans in 2024 will defect because they did not get the fundamental change – an end to forever wars and a focus on affordability – the voted for. The  capitalist system writ large does not work for them and they figure “might as well break it.” .
  • Young voters also want an end to genocide in Gaza. Social media and the internet ensure that everyone sees video of children being killed there whether they want to or not. This will cause young (and some older) Americans to seek the fundamental change they want from candidates who will promise to stop this genocide. 
  • Culture war rhetoric about trans kids and gay marriage no longer resonate with rural Americans while rising fuel prices and tariffs destroy their farms and the foreign markets for their produce. 
  • Voters are sick of watching billionaires push artificial intelligence from private planes and yachts while AI takes their jobs and housing, fuel, and grocery prices rise rapidly. 
  • Even though wages are rising with prices, people don’t feel this because right to work and at will employment laws make white collar workers anxious about their financial futures. News reports of layoffs have an impact.
  • Health care costs are out of control and voters know whom to blame: health insurance companies and politicians who argue that if you can’t afford it you don’t deserve it. Most voters work very hard and are beginning to become pissed at Republicans who tell them to just work harder. The (correct) feeling that the system is rigged against regular workers is gaining traction. $225B in medical debt has begun to hit Republican voters and it matters.
  • Screaming about who loves and who hates America doesn’t resonate as well during hard times. Voters, especially young voters, don’t have many reasons to love a country that leaves them behind while making them feel like it’s their fault after they did all the right things.
  • Americans want criminal immigrants deported but despise the heavy-handed Gestapo style tactics ICE uses. Watching federal agents who often refuse to identify themselves and do not wear uniforms randomly round up people because they have brown skin leaves a bad taste in their mouths. It doesn’t help that they shoot or assault citizens and then tell us that we won’t have a problem if we just comply.
  • Traditional GOP voters in rural areas, especially farmers, have been hit hard by higher fuel prices (especially diesel) and by tariffs that killed foreign markets for crops like soybeans. Rural America does not have diverse economies, and when agriculture dies the small towns where they do business struggle.
  • Democrats have effectively tied affordability to Trump’s obvious corruption and higher prices to Trump tariff and war policies.

There’s a lot more. What Corey Doctorow calls “enshittification” of everything. Data centers popping up everywhere. Everyone everywhere trying to nickel and dime us wherever we turn (tip jars at fast food restaurants and service fees for everything).

Continue reading →

Democrat Haley Stevens Endorses GOP Candidate for US Senate, Mike Rogers

I’ve studied politics for most of fifty years, and actively participated as a Democrat for most of the last 25. I worked in Kentucky politics right after retiring from the Army ran for the Virginia state legislature twice since 2019. I’ve never seen anything like the Haley Stevens endorsement of Mike Rogers for US Senate in Michigan.

Losing primary candidates have a few options with respect to how they play the general election. Most throw their support to the winner and ask their supporters to do the same because this is the best way to keep their position in the Party. This matters, because the Party (both the administrative establishment and its voters) has a lot of say over who gets future nominations and support.

After contentious primaries, a candidate may and often does profess support for the winner but doesn’t do a lot of work to get their supporters to show up and help the general election candidate win. They don’t appear at campaign events or help them raise money (for example by sharing donor lists or making calls on the winner’s behalf).

After Abdul El-Sayed won the Democratic primary for US Senate in Michigan, it appeared that Stevens would follow the second path. She conceded and congratulated El Sayed, but didn’t seem to take an active role in helping him win. This sort of makes sense after a fairly bitter primary during which El Sayed criticized Stevens strongly for her position on aid to Israel and her willingness to accept corporate political action committee (PAC) money.

Now she has decided to endorse Mike Rogers, the GOP nominee, two days before Election Day.

In Virginia, this amounts to formal resignation from Democratic Party committees, and I can’t imagine that significant numbers of Michigan Democrats would welcome someone who endorsed a Republican who consistently votes against protecting reproductive health care rights for women and supports fetal personhood.

In an interview with Anderson Cooper, Stevens cited “growing anger” from the El Sayed campaign as her reason for her decision, but this makes little sense given that she’d said the day before that she looked forward to appearing with him at a church service and later campaign event on November 1, the day she broke from the party. Instead, she attended a service at a black church in Detroit instead.

It looks to me like her decision has much to do with her position on Israel and influence from her fiancé, Jason Turkish.

Jason Turkish, the fiancé of former Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Haley Stevens, accused the party’s Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed of escalating rhetoric that makes Jewish people unsafe, deepening an intraparty feud days before the midterms.

The immediate fight centers partly on a digital advertisement produced by Rebellion PAC, an outside group supporting El-Sayed that describes itself as a movement that rejects “the corporate-driven status quo” and stands “against the establishment.”

The advertisement shows a couple grocery shopping and talking about putting back a carton of eggs because “we have to set that $7 aside for killing Palestinians,” before criticizing U.S. military assistance to Israel in its war in Gaza. Stevens, a U.S. Representative who lost to El-Sayed in the August primary, characterized the advertisement as antisemitic and called on him to condemn it.

I am not a fan of this ad because I think it muddles the message by failing to clearly connect the high cost of groceries to taxpayer funds sent to Israel. But it points out a key issue: that the US supports genocide in Gaza with taxpayer funds, and I’m not surprised that the Zionist crowd tries to frame this as anti-semitism rather than anti-genocide.

Turkish has pushed the “El Sayed is a terrorist with ties to the Muslim Brotherhood” narrative and endorsed Rogers on October 28. Further, Stevens is apparently converting to Judaism as their wedding approaches. And apparently, some of Stevens’ close circle have become concerned about her relationship with Turkish. It’s important to be careful about characterizing others’ relationships, but former Michigan governor Jim Blanchard, in an interview with Gongwer News Service (paywall), described Turkish pressuring Stevens at dinner to support Rogers, saying: “He was working her over.”

Much of El Sayed’s criticism of Stevens focused on her acceptance of millions of dollars in campaign funding from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), which is Israel’s key lobbying organization in the US. El Sayed has pointed out many times that he believe the US should be spending taxpayer dollars on feeding American children, not bombing Palestinian children. He did not condemn the Rebellion PAC ad.

All of this makes me wonder if AIPAC leaders believe El Sayed is poised to win and wanted a hail mary endorsement from Stevens to see if they could get Rogers over the finish line in a very close election.

It also makes me wonder if AIPAC and the GOP promised her something in return, and what that might be.

Will the Gerrymanders Work?

Texas and Florida both redrew Congressional districts this year in an effort to protect the GOP majority in Congress. To do this, they used precinct voter data to create more districts with Republican majorities (at least according to the most recent election results).

It’s worth taking a look at whether this might backfire for a couple of reasons.

Success rests on the assumption that voting patterns won’t change much. That is, precincts that voted 52% for Trump in 2024 will vote close to that percentage for Congress in 2026. This is very unlikely. Changes in the economy caused by immigration enforcement, rising fuel prices caused by the Iran war, and a general perception that things have not improved since Trump won a second term in 2024 well almost certainly cause many people to change their votes, and few of those will go from blue to red. The best example of this in Texas is the apparent return to the Democratic Party by Hispanics.

This matters because to draw a new map with fewer Democratic Party seats means moving blue precincts into red districts and red districts to blue. This means making what used to be easy wins a little closer by moving those votes to make new majority districts.

But if voting patterns change a lot, some of the new districts are now vulnerable, since it went from a 60% district to a 55% district. In a way, Virginia’s First District is an example. When the Commonwealth drew new districts after the 2020 Census, the new CD 01 lost red precincts in Hanover and Stafford Counties while picking up bluer precincts in Henrico and Chesterfield. Wittman historically won the seat with a 56% plus vote total, but these changes moved the District about 2% to the left. With a big enough blue wave, this could mean a Democrat can win and Shannon Taylor might pull it off.

For a quick look at whether the Texas and Florida redistricting could backfire, check out this New Republic article on Nine Gerrymandered Districts to watch on Tuesday.

When Republicans set out to redistrict in the middle of the decade, they thought they were all but ensuring more seats in the House. But, one week before the midterm elections, many of Republicans’ tailor-made districts are looking vulnerable. Here are nine districts to watch on election night to gauge the success of gerrymandering in Florida and Texas:

FL-9
In this Central Florida district, Democratic Representative Darren Sotois running against Navy reservist Dan Green. Polling shows an even race, and the Cook Political Report rates the race as “likely D.”

FL-14
Trump won this Tampa Bay-area district by 11 points in 2024, but the race is now rated as a “toss-up” by the Cook Political Report. Democratic Representative Kathy Castor, who is leading in polls, is hoping to defend her seat from Republican Mike Beltran.

FL-25
Democratic Representative Jared Moskowitz is facing Republican Scott Singer in this South Florida district. Polls give mixed messages, but the Cook Political Report moved the race from “toss-up” to “lean D” in mid-October.

FL-22
Democrat Pia Dandiya is up against Republican Casey Askar. Limited polling shows a tight race, with a small advantage for Dandiya. The race is considered a “toss-up.”

TX-32
A lack of polling makes this race hard to judge, but a Harvard-ElectIt forecast gives Democrat Dan Barrios only a 20 percent chance of beating Republican Jace Yarbrough.

TX-9
The Cook Political Report considers this race “likely R” after a leftward shift from “solid R” in late September. Polls show Republican Alex Mealer ahead of Democrat Leticia Gutierrez.

TX-35
Another toss-up race, and this one could be anyone’s game. Polls show Democrat Johnny Garcia neck-and-neck with his GOP opponent, Carlos De La Cruz.

TX-28
Democratic Representative Henry Cuellar has held this seat for 11 terms, and recent polls suggest he’ll win another against Republican Tano Tijerina. Last week, the Cook Political Report shifted the race from “lean D” to “likely D.”

TX-34
Democratic Representative Vicente Gonzales is facing former federal prosecutor Eric Flores in this race, which recently moved left from “toss-up” to “lean D.” Polls suggest Gonzalez is in the lead.

Quick caveat on polls: Republicans have tended to over perform polls in recent years because respondents hide the fact that they plan to vote red or because pollsters failed to properly parse the voting population (that is, they included too few Republicans in their samples).

I’ve read that this year pollsters have tried to account for this. We’ll see.

Game Recognizes Game

According to ProPublica (a very important investigative journalism magazine that everyone should read), Trump’s Department of Justice intervened to rescue Susan Collins from an FBI investigation into what amounts to bribery.

“But the company did have such a proposal: Navatek was hungry for more government contracts in Maine. If they cut a big check, the CEO told Reed, Navatek wanted Collins to guarantee tens of millions of dollars in additional federal funding.

To skirt campaign finance laws and conceal the source of the funds, Navatek planned to funnel the donation through a shell company. The CEO wanted assurance that Collins would know where the money came from. Reed confirmed that she would, the executive said — and that Navatek would get its government contracts.


After the Corner Bakery meeting, Navatek’s CEO, Martin Kao, sent an initial $150,000 to the Collins super PAC using the shell company. Two months later, he told Navatek executives that Collins committed to getting the company $32 million in naval contracts, according to an internal company email reviewed by ProPublica.


Three years later, Kao holed up in a conference room to recount the Corner Bakery meeting to a group of four FBI agents and federal prosecutors. The FBI had seen through his shell company ruse, and in 2022 a grand jury indicted him for making illegal campaign contributions. No one working for Collins was charged.
“

In fact, Trump’s DOJ no longer investigates corruption in any meaningful way, and is more likely to do what it did here when faced with real corruption: look the other way and drop investigations when it serves his purposes.

Instead, Trump’s DOJ files specious charges against political opponents, former aides who don’t spread his lies, or just people he doesn’t like.

The Speech That Broke the Frame

How the 2026 State of the Force Became a Stress Test for American Civil–Military Norms

By Scott Konopasek

One would think that a Secretary of Defense addressing a room full of senior officers would be boring, unheralded, and ignored by the media. That used to be the case. But like so much else in American governance, even this has become political theater.

Hegseth’s “State of the Force” is not an established Pentagon ritual. It’s not a long‑running institutional tradition. It is a new political invention — created and branded by Hegseth and the Trump administration, first informally in 2025 and then formalized in 2026.

Last week, Hegseth delivered a speech that sounded less like a briefing for generals and admirals and more like a campaign rally spliced with a revival meeting. He fired off slurs at transgender troops, mocked “woke generals,” invoked scripture as operational guidance, and announced a 20 percent purge of senior officers as if he were reading off a grocery list. He unveiled a new Office of Religious Affairs reporting directly to him — bypassing the chaplain corps — and declared that the “real battle is spiritual.”

The Atlantic described the room as “frozen.” General officers sat stiffly, hands folded, faces blank. They knew better than to cheer. A small number of junior officers clapped at a few applause lines before they, too, went quiet. They could feel the line between civilian control and partisan political theater bending. And they also knew something else: the speech wasn’t aimed at them. It was aimed at an audience outside the building — a political audience.

A Purge Not Called a Purge

Hegseth insisted that firing 10 percent of generals and eliminating another 10 percent of billets was “accountability,” not a purge. But the officers listening understood the message: loyalty is now a qualification, neutrality is risky, and dissent is terminal.

Mid‑career officers — the people who actually make the Department of Defense function — reacted with fear and confusion in internal morale surveys. They worry about promotion pathways, ideological vetting, and the sudden disappearance of mentors and institutional memory within their service. Senior leaders have warned the White House that readiness is already suffering.

The military is built on consistency and continuity. You cannot remove one‑fifth of senior leadership and rewrite long‑standing norms without shaking the ranks and degrading readiness.

The Culture War in Uniform

The speech’s most quoted line — “No fatties, no trannies, no beardos, no weirdos, no wimps, no radicals. Just warriors.” — ricocheted across social media within minutes. Some veteran influencers celebrated it as a return to “warrior ethos.” But veterans who have actually led troops — the ones who understand cohesion and morale — saw something else.

Hegseth wasn’t describing standards. He was describing identity — who belongs and who doesn’t — and testosterone was one of the markers he used.

Democratic veterans in Congress responded immediately. Pat Ryan called the speech “pathetic” and “beneath the dignity of the office.” Chris Deluzio warned that the purge had “destabilized the military” and distracted from real war‑fighting needs. Their criticism wasn’t ideological. It was professional.

Republican veterans, by contrast, stayed quiet. Conservative veteran organizations didn’t weigh in. Their silence wasn’t accidental. It reflected the political pressures surrounding the administration.

Progressive veteran groups treated the speech as a direct threat to military professionalism. They focused less on the slurs and more on the structural message: that senior leadership could be purged for ideological reasons, and that religious identity might become a criterion for advancement.

The veteran community is not monolithic, and the speech exposed the fault lines with clarity. Culture warriors cheered the rhetoric. Veterans who value the Constitution and the rule of law over political loyalty saw it as an assault on the military’s independence.

The Religious Turn

The most overlooked part of the speech may be the most consequential: the creation of the Office of Religious Affairs.

Hegseth framed it as a way to “restore spiritual readiness.” Religious‑liberty advocates heard something else: a breach of the First Amendment. Military.com reported that the office immediately sparked a “legal church–state fight.” Constitutional scholars warned that the Pentagon cannot endorse a particular religious worldview, especially in an institution where obedience is not optional.

Christian and non‑Christian religious groups raised concerns about sectarian favoritism. Many church leaders warned against weaponizing faith. Even conservative Christian circles had raised concerns about religious freedom well before Hegseth’s announcement.

The LDS Church’s Constitutional Counterpoint

Recently, Dallin H. Oaks, president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter‑day Saints — and a former state supreme court justice — spoke at the National Cathedral about religious freedom as a constitutional value. He emphasized constitutional balance, pluralism, and restraint — a message that stands in sharp contrast to the speech’s fusion of scripture, military aggression, and political identity.

Oaks urged Americans to build coalitions across disagreements and resist absolutism. He emphasized fairness for all, constitutional boundaries, and the need for peacemaking in a polarized nation. Retired federal judge Thomas Griffith praised Oaks’ message as a roadmap for navigating political and religious differences without coercion or contempt.

The LDS Church’s stance was clear: religious liberty protects everyone, government must avoid sectarian messaging, and faith should not be weaponized.

The Pope’s Moral Counterpoint

Where LDS leaders emphasized constitutional balance, Pope Leo XIV emphasized moral authority — but both pointed toward the same danger: the manipulation of religion to justify military action.

Just days after Hegseth prayed for “overwhelming violence” and “no mercy,” Pope Leo declared during Palm Sunday Mass that “God ignores the prayers of leaders who wage war and have hands full of blood.” He warned that Jesus “cannot be used to justify war.” Two weeks later, he condemned “those who manipulate religion for political or military ends.” And in May, his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas rejected autonomous warfare — the centerpiece of Hegseth’s AUTOWARCOM — as morally unacceptable.

This wasn’t theological commentary. It was a direct moral counter‑argument to the worldview Hegseth presented.

Historical Parallels — and Why They Don’t Fit

It’s tempting to reach for historical analogies to make sense of a moment like this. But the closest parallels don’t explain Hegseth’s speech — they highlight how many guardrails had to bend for it to happen.

Truman fired MacArthur to protect civil–military norms; Hegseth strained them. The Revolt of the Admirals was about policy, not ideology; today’s officers aren’t revolting, they’re afraid. Rumsfeld pushed radical transformation, but he didn’t lace it with slurs or scripture. Cold War civil religion was intentionally broad and nonsectarian. Chaplaincy battles were about enforcing neutrality, not reversing it. Foreign examples — Turkey, Hungary, Russia — show what happens when militaries become ideological instruments.

The real parallel is the absence of a parallel. The United States has never seen a civilian Secretary of Defense announce a purge of generals, use slurs against service members, invoke scripture as operational guidance, create a religious office reporting directly to him, frame war as a spiritual battle, and unveil a new autonomous‑warfare command — all in the same speech.

The analogies don’t normalize the speech. They show how far outside the norms it sits.

The Real Issue

The temptation is to treat the State of the Force speech as another entry in America’s endless culture war. But that misses the point.

The military is not a culture‑war battleground. It is a constitutional institution. Its legitimacy depends on nonpartisanship, professionalism, and continuity. When political actors treat it as a vehicle for ideological purification, they weaken the very thing they claim to strengthen.

Hegseth derides DEI initiatives while championing meritocracy as if the two are in opposition. Purges don’t build readiness. Slurs don’t build cohesion. Spiritual mandates don’t build trust. And speeches that sound like rallies don’t build institutions. Purges born of ideological purity tests, loyalty, and testosterone levels mock the notion of merit.

Theatrics have never been a force multiplier.

The Foggy Bottom Line

The 2026 State of the Force speech didn’t just reveal political polarization. It revealed institutional fragility. It showed how quickly civil–military norms can be bent, how easily rhetoric can become policy, and how deeply veterans themselves are divided about what the military should be.

But it also showed something else: the general officers in that room still know where the line is. They sat quietly. They didn’t cheer. They didn’t turn the speech into a spectacle.

Their integrity and professionalism held the line, even as the line was being probed and tested.

That, at least for now, should give us confidence in our military leadership.